• Press Releases
    • Submit a press release
    • Read All
  • Contact us
Advertise
Bitcoinist.com
Buy Neo Pepe
No Result
View All Result
🚀 BUY NEO PEPE PROTOCOL 🚀
  • Bitcoin
    • News
    • Price
    • Businesses
    • Acceptance
    • Technology
    • Investment
    • Regulation
    • Reviews
    • All Bitcoin News
  • Altcoins
    • News
    • Price
    • Ethereum
    • Ripple
    • Litecoin
    • EOS
    • NAGA
    • All Altcoin News
  • Tech
    • Blockchain
    • Security
    • FinTech
    • Price
      • Bitcoin Price
      • Ethereum Price
      • Binance Coin Price
      • Litecoin Price
  • Industry
    • Industry News
    • Press Releases
  • How to
    • Buy gift cards/mobile Top Ups with Cryptos
    • What Is Bitcoin?
    • Best Bitcoin Wallet
    • Bitcoin vs Ethereum
    • Why Use Blockchain Technology?
    • Bitcoin Cash ABC vs. Bitcoin Cash SV
    • How to Buy Cryptocurrency
    • How to do Crypto Gambling
      • Crypto Casinos
        • Ethereum Casinos
        • Solana Casinos
        • LiteCoin Casinos
        • DogeCoin Casinos
        • Live Crypto Casinos
        • New Casinos
        • Instant Withdrawal Casinos
        • Cash App Casinos
        • No KYC Casinos
        • VPN Casinos
        • Offshore Casinos
          • Crypto Casinos IT
          • Crypto Casinos ES
            • All Guides
          • Crypto Casinos JP
          • Crypto Casinos SG
          • Crypto Casinos MY
          • Crypto Casinos KR
          • No GAMSTOP Casinos in UK
          • No Cruks Casinos NL
      • Crypto Betting
        • No ID sportsbooks
    • Play Crypto Games
      • Crypto Poker
      • Crypto Slots
      • Crypto Blackjack
      • Crypto Crash Gambling
        • Aviator Sites
      • Plinko
    • Bitcoin Mining
    • Best Bitcoin Brokers
    • Best Bitcoin Forex Brokers
    • How To Earn Bitcoin
    • What is Facebook Libra?
    • Ripple and XRP: The Complete Guide
  • Events
  • Play Games
Breaking News: Polymarket Set To Go Live In The US Following CFTC Approval, Says CEO
🚀 BUY NEO PEPE PROTOCOL 🚀
  • Bitcoin
    • News
    • Price
    • Businesses
    • Acceptance
    • Technology
    • Investment
    • Regulation
    • Reviews
    • All Bitcoin News
  • Altcoins
    • News
    • Price
    • Ethereum
    • Ripple
    • Litecoin
    • EOS
    • NAGA
    • All Altcoin News
  • Tech
    • Blockchain
    • Security
    • FinTech
    • Price
      • Bitcoin Price
      • Ethereum Price
      • Binance Coin Price
      • Litecoin Price
  • Industry
    • Industry News
    • Press Releases
  • How to
    • Buy gift cards/mobile Top Ups with Cryptos
    • What Is Bitcoin?
    • Best Bitcoin Wallet
    • Bitcoin vs Ethereum
    • Why Use Blockchain Technology?
    • Bitcoin Cash ABC vs. Bitcoin Cash SV
    • How to Buy Cryptocurrency
    • How to do Crypto Gambling
      • Crypto Casinos
        • Ethereum Casinos
        • Solana Casinos
        • LiteCoin Casinos
        • DogeCoin Casinos
        • Live Crypto Casinos
        • New Casinos
        • Instant Withdrawal Casinos
        • Cash App Casinos
        • No KYC Casinos
        • VPN Casinos
        • Offshore Casinos
          • Crypto Casinos IT
          • Crypto Casinos ES
            • All Guides
          • Crypto Casinos JP
          • Crypto Casinos SG
          • Crypto Casinos MY
          • Crypto Casinos KR
          • No GAMSTOP Casinos in UK
          • No Cruks Casinos NL
      • Crypto Betting
        • No ID sportsbooks
    • Play Crypto Games
      • Crypto Poker
      • Crypto Slots
      • Crypto Blackjack
      • Crypto Crash Gambling
        • Aviator Sites
      • Plinko
    • Bitcoin Mining
    • Best Bitcoin Brokers
    • Best Bitcoin Forex Brokers
    • How To Earn Bitcoin
    • What is Facebook Libra?
    • Ripple and XRP: The Complete Guide
  • Events
  • Play Games
Bitcoinist.com
No Result
View All Result
Breaking News: Polymarket Set To Go Live In The US Following CFTC Approval, Says CEO
Post-Merge, Ethereum mining rig

Post-Merge Question From The SEC: Is ETH Under Proof-Of-Stake A Security?

Eduardo Próspero
by Eduardo Próspero
2 years ago
·
Posted in Ethereum, SEC
Trusted Editorial content, reviewed by leading industry experts and seasoned editors. Ad Disclosure

We’re in a post-merge world. And the SEC is looking at Ethereum once again after the substantial changes it recently went through. Word on the street is that Chairman Gary Gensler, speaking post-merge for the first time, insinuated Ethereum could now be a security. What did Gensler say, exactly? What is a security? Is the SEC onto something by targeting the post-merge Ethereum?

Related Reading: Why Crypto Regulation Puts CFTC In Crosshairs With SEC Once Again

On the one hand, Ethereum’s mining could’ve been the element that kept the organization out of the unregistered security category. Post-merge, there’s no mining and there’s still the issue of the huge premine at Ethereum’s beginning. On the other hand, we could say that the miner’s replacements, the validators, are not getting dividends. The reward is compensation for their work. Under that lens, staking wouldn’t be an investment of any kind. 

Years ago, the SEC said that Ethereum is a commodity and not a security. The changes were substantial, however. ETH is a whole different animal post-merge. Does the Securities and Exchange Commission’s Chairman Gary Gensler sees it as a target? Or are people reading too much into his words?

What Did Chairman Gensler Say About A Post-Merge Ethereum 

Nothing, actually. His statements were about cryptocurrencies in general. However, after a congressional hearing, Gensler told reporters: 

“From the coin’s perspective…that’s another indicia that under the Howey test, the investing public is anticipating profits based on the efforts of others.”

What is the Howey test, though? According to Investopedia, the Howey test refers to “four criteria to determine whether an investment contract exists.” The Supreme Court established them by ruling in “SEC v. W.J. Howey Co.” in 1946. The criteria are:

  1. An investment of money
  2. In a common enterprise
  3. With the expectation of profit
  4. To be derived from the efforts of others

So, that’s what Chairman Gensler is referring to in his post-congressional hearing soundbite. Was he talking about Ethereum specifically? Is the post-merge Ethereum a security? According to Gabor Gurbacs, Strategy Advisor at VanEck among other things, it’s not about that. Even if it’s not a security, Ethereum was bound to attract regulatory attention post-merge.

To be clear, I am not saying that ETH is necessarily a security because of its proof model, but regulators do talk about staking in the context of dividends which if one feature of what securities laws call a "common enterprise". There are other factors in the Howey test too.

— Gabor Gurbacs (@gaborgurbacs) September 15, 2022

And Ethereum might very well be a security, according to Gurbacs:

“I am not saying that ETH is necessarily a security because of its proof model, but regulators do talk about staking in the context of dividends which if one feature of what securities laws call a “common enterprise”. There are other factors in the Howey test too.”

ETHUSD price chart for 09/16/2022 - TradingView

ETH price chart for 09/16/2022 on Gemini | Source: ETH/USD on TradingView.com

Is Staking Similar To… Lending?

The WSJ contextualized a tiny but very telling phrase by Chairman Gensler:

“If an intermediary such as a crypto exchange offers staking services to its customers, Mr. Gensler said, it “looks very similar—with some changes of labeling—to lending.”

Does it, though? It seems like a stretch at first hearing, but… the staker lends its ETH to the exchange and gets dividends in return? Maybe there’s a case to be made against the post-merge Ethereum. That’s not what professor, investor, and marketing/strategy executive Adam Cochran thinks, though. “At first brush, the idea of “buy token, stake token, earn token” can look like a security – I get that,” he concludes after a compelling and elaborate thread. 

Related Reading: Chamber Of Digital Commerce Calls Out The SEC, Argues The US Needs A Bitcoin ETF

“But, with a nuanced understanding of the operation of a proof-of-stake chain, I think it fails to be a security even in a generous reading of the Howey test.

If the SEC were to argue that Ethereum is a security, I personally don’t see that view being made *more* likely by the switch to proof of stake, and I certainly don’t think anyone has grounds to state it as such definitively.”

42/43

If the SEC were to argue that Ethereum is a security, I personally don't see that view being made *more* likely by the switch to proof of stake, and I certainly don't think anyone has grounds to state it as such definitively.

— Adam Cochran (adamscochran.eth) (@adamscochran) July 24, 2022

To add to the pile, Gurbacs, who made an argument for the Ethereum-is-a-security case, had this to say as a conclusion:

“I believe that computer programs that are not used to raise money or promise dividends should not be categorized as a security. Tokens and small businesses need a lighter and cheaper regulatory regime so that they can register. The current system is complex & cost prohibitive.”

Is that the way forward?

Featured Image by Лечение Наркомании from Pixabay | Charts by TradingView

Chamber of Digital Commerce, SEC logo

Editorial Process for bitcoinist is centered on delivering thoroughly researched, accurate, and unbiased content. We uphold strict sourcing standards, and each page undergoes diligent review by our team of top technology experts and seasoned editors. This process ensures the integrity, relevance, and value of our content for our readers.
ShareTweetShareShare

Sign Up for Our Newsletter!

For updates and exclusive offers enter your email.

I consent to my submitted data being collected and stored.
Eduardo Próspero

Eduardo Próspero

Follow

Eduardo Prospero is an author, a content writer, and a professional rapper. A Bitcoin maximalist in disguise. Working on a Bitcoin book. Beware of my Telegram impersonator!

Full Profile

Related Posts

Ethereum

Just 10 Wallets Control Majority Of Ethereum Supply: How Do Other ETH Tokens Compare?

8 hours ago
ethereum_eth_ethusd_optimized

Ethereum Open Interest Holds Firm at $8.4B: Why Traders Aren’t Flinching Despite Price Pressure

14 hours ago
Ethereum

This Company Plans To Go Public With An Ethereum Treasury — Here’s How Much ETH They Bought

1 day ago
Ethereum

Ethereum Leads Market Rotation Amid Shifting Liquidity On Binance, Is A Rebound In Sight?

1 day ago
Bitcoin vs Ethereum

Ethereum Price More Influenced By Off-Chain Markets Than Bitcoin, Data May Suggest

1 day ago
Ethereum Buys Surge As Jack Ma-Linked Yunfeng Financial Invests $44 Million

Ethereum Buys Surge As Jack Ma-Linked Yunfeng Financial Invests $44 Million

1 day ago
Please login to join discussion

Premium Sponsors

Press Releases

  • miner

    7 Trending Crypto Mining Apps This Year That Give Free...

    17 minutes ago
  • mining

    6 Most Reliable Crypto Mining Software to Help Miners...

    1 hour ago
  • MemeCore...

    7 hours ago
  • XRP is expected to break through $7. APT Miner helps...

    14 hours ago
  • miner

    Expectations of a Federal Reserve rate cut and demand for...

    18 hours ago

Bitcoin news portal providing breaking news, guides, price analysis about decentralized digital money & blockchain technology.

Buy Neo Pepe

Bitcoin

  • News
  • Price
  • Businesses
  • Acceptance
  • Technology
  • Investment
  • Regulation
  • Reviews

Altcoins

  • News
  • Price
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • EOS

Categories

  • Blockchain
  • Security
  • FinTech
  • Technology
  • Trending
  • Breaking News
  • Press Releases
  • How to

About Us

  • Advertise
  • Contact us
  • Editorial Policy
  • Privacy Policy
© 2025 Bitcoinist.com. All Rights Reserved.
  • Bitcoin
    • News
    • Price
    • Businesses
    • Acceptance
    • Technology
    • Investment
    • Regulation
    • Reviews
    • All Bitcoin News
  • Altcoins
    • News
    • Price
    • Ethereum
    • Ripple
    • Litecoin
    • EOS
    • NAGA
    • All Altcoin News
  • Tech
    • Blockchain
    • Security
    • FinTech
    • Price
      • Bitcoin Price
      • Ethereum Price
      • Binance Coin Price
      • Litecoin Price
  • Industry
    • Industry News
    • Press Releases
  • How to
    • Buy gift cards/mobile Top Ups with Cryptos
    • What Is Bitcoin?
    • Best Bitcoin Wallet
    • Bitcoin vs Ethereum
    • Why Use Blockchain Technology?
    • Bitcoin Cash ABC vs. Bitcoin Cash SV
    • How to Buy Cryptocurrency
    • How to do Crypto Gambling
      • Crypto Casinos
      • Crypto Betting
    • Play Crypto Games
      • Crypto Poker
      • Crypto Slots
      • Crypto Blackjack
      • Crypto Crash Gambling
      • Plinko
    • Bitcoin Mining
    • Best Bitcoin Brokers
    • Best Bitcoin Forex Brokers
    • How To Earn Bitcoin
    • What is Facebook Libra?
    • Ripple and XRP: The Complete Guide
  • Events
  • Play Games
Advertise

© 2025 Bitcoinist. All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy Center or Cookie Policy.